Self evident assessment

I hate buzz words! I really do. But in education, as in any profession, we use them all of the time. I am guilty of it too, but there is one particular use that I especially hate. The political use of educational buzzwords by reformers and politicians to promote standardization and testing. I hate the current movement focusing on standard curriculum and tests for every student. I have always believed that individual, authentic assessment by professional teachers is the better course. I also believe that when students are doing authentic tasks that really matter that their learning is obvious to anyone who takes the time to talk to them. I have not always felt the ability to express this clearly to others though. Usually the best way is through stories and examples.

Then I saw John Hunter’s Ted Talk about his World Peace Game. It is a fantastic simulation that is structured but open-ended. The whole video is worth your time but I want to focus on the segment from 14:40-16:55.

I love what John Hunter says:
       I get chills every time I see that. That’s the kind of engagement
      we want to have happen. And I can’t design that, I can’t plan
      that, and I can’t even test that. But it is self evident 
      assessment. We know that that is an authentic assessment of 
      learning. You know we have a lot of data but I think sometimes
      we go beyond data with the truth of learning of what is going on.

So as much as I hate buzz words I propose a new one to fight against people who say that we need more “data” (test scores) or “common assessments” (test scores) to help improve “student achievement” (test scores): self evident assessment.

When students, especially in the PBL model, present authentic work to real audiences the skills and learning are apparent and obvious. I do not hear people asking how teachers are assessing in these situations. On the other hand testing is a great way to assess worksheet dittos and questions from the textbook. Maybe the reason that we have so many politicians and reformers pushing the testing agenda is because too many teachers for too long have not given students the opportunity to engage in activities which produce self evident assessment.

I believe as politicians push educators into testing and more testing leading to test prep and more test prep that parents will seek out and demand these type of learning experiences for their children.

About Michael Kaechele

I like learning, sharing, technology, math, history, and concrete.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Self evident assessment

  1. Thank you for this post… I also share the same dislike for those buzz words. Another buzzword I hate is benchmarks! Thank you for this blog – very much appreciated!

    Like

  2. brianneises says:

    Thanks for sharing this great resource! A good reminder to ‘clear a space’ for learning rather than filling it up with what we assume students should know, rather than what they can discover on their own.

    It’s a challenge to set up learning environments and tasks that foster inquiry that can lead to true learning, and not just a discovery of what we as teachers already know the answer to. I appreciated his honest approach to letting the students know that he didn’t know the answers already!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s