The Continuing Saga of a Water Bottle Inquiry

IMG_4253Today, students took their action to the streets–well the streets of Yokohama International School.

In December, right before the holidays, students in my grade 5 class followed their heart and inquired into plastic water bottle sales that were happening at school. The high school Business Studies class students were selling water bottles to make money. I think their goal was to create a business and make a profit.

The students in my class and I didn’t like it so we considered what to do about it. At that time, students decided to research plastic water bottles detrimental effects and create a presentation to show the Business Studies class. It went well. For more detail on December’s inquiry, see Pursuing Inquiry Action .

After the holidays, the Business Studies didn’t return to selling water bottles, and my students thought they were victorious. However, several weeks ago, the boys returned to the hallway with a table of sandwiches and a few water bottles. They appearedIMG_4254 to have taken a different turn and were now focusing on sandwiches as the main item, with a water on the side.

We talked in class if students would support them. Some liked the idea they had turned to sandwiches. Others said no, they were still selling water bottles, so no. Everyone decided to let the business go on and see what happened.

This week, things changed. The Business Studies students came back with a table of water bottles–some large, some small and two different prices. It was the same water from before: Kirkland water from Costco. They had rows and rows of water for sale for 50 yen and 100 yen (pretty cheap).

Students were angry. A few asked why they were doing it when they had supposedly said they wouldn’t sell water. They told my students: “Welcome to the real world.”

IMG_4262As can be expected, that didn’t go over well. We brainstormed options. The students decided they would sell ice cream to counteract sales. An interesting proposition. They decided, though, they needed immediate action.

Today, they made signs of protest and stuck them on cardboard sticks. The signs read: “The Earth is crying” or “Water is free. Use the water fountain.” “Save the oceans.”

I talked with them about doing a silent protest and just holding up signs. They stood near the table, but not in front of it (as to not block customers). They did well. What brave kids.

The Business Studies class were shocked and laughing. All high school and middle school students on break took a lot of pictures and gave them thumbs up. Teachers stopped by. Crowds surrounded them.

Only one high school student bought a water bottle. He sheepishly went past the picketers and gave his money. In fact, he asked quietly if he could. My grade 5 students were elated, and now more want to join in the picket line. It feels good when you can take charge and do some action. I think my students are learning that.

About kdceci

I am a PYP Coordinator in Mumbai, India. I have a daughter who is a senior this year in an IB school. From the US originally, I have been in Asia the last 13 years. I am passionate about inquiry-driven education, collaboration, and ensuring kids get to continue to be kids that play, create and think as long as they can. Outside of school, l love to write, read, hike, run, meditate and travel.
This entry was posted in Inquiry. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The Continuing Saga of a Water Bottle Inquiry

  1. Ms. Kris says:

    I am so far beyond astounded. That’s what I call ACTION!


  2. Pak Liam says:

    Love it! What brave risk takers you have!


  3. Lynn Beaton says:

    I would love to talk to you more about this as my grade 5/6 class has just started a year long inquiry into PET water bottles. How can I connect with you?


  4. Kristen says:

    Very cool! It was 2 years ago, but email:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s